"'Tis the gift to be simple"

Aaron Copland meets the Shakers

 

 

In November of 1974, the distinguished composer Aaron Copland (1900-1990)
was in Cleveland, Ohio for a celebration of "Aaron Copland Week."

The week included concerts of his music, including the Suite from "Appalachian Spring," by the Cleveland Orchestra, conducted by Copland and other Copland works conducted by Cleveland Orchestra Director, Lorin Maazel.

Other concerts were held during that week by various musicians.

There was also a showing of the 1939 movie, OF MICE AND MEN, with the film score by Copland, who seemed very pleased by this attention to his film score.

One of the honors was receiving an honorary key to the City of Cleveland by the mayor.

I attended many of the events and wished I could introduce Copland to the Shakers, if they happened to be in the area.

Well, happily, my wish came true.

Copland meets the Shakers for the first and only time

At the same time Copland was in Cleveland, there were several Shakers from Sabbathday Lake, Maine visiting in nearby Shaker Heights, Ohio.

For those not aware of the Shakers, they are America's most prolific religious communal sect in their music with over 10,000 texts and tunes written from the 1780s to 1959.

After a quick phone call to the hotel where Copland was staying in Cleveland, I was able to arrange for him to meet the Shakers while he was attending a Case Western Reserve University music student gathering.

At that meeting, I asked Copland to sign a copy of his vocal setting for "Simple Gifts."

Later that same day, at a workshop for local teachers, the Shakers sang a few of their favorite songs and they mentioned their pleasure of being introduced to Aaron Copland.

That day of November 9, 1974, when Copland met the Shakers from Sabbathday Lake, will always be special to me, since I was able to introduce the composer I most admired to the Shakers I also admired and they both met for the first and only time.

It was truly a meeting of minds and both shared a mutual admiration for the Shaker dance song with words like the opening four lines:

'Tis the gift to be simple, 'tis the gift to be free,
'Tis the gift to come down, where we ought to be,
And when we find ourselves in the place just right,
"Twill be in the valley of love and delight.


-- Roger Lee Hall,
November 2014/ updated: Februrary 2024

 

Here are two CDs from the interview by Roger Lee Hall
with Aaron Copland at his home in July of 1980:

 

A Conversation with Aaron Copland (AMRC 0005)

 

 

Gentle Words - A Shaker Music Sampler (AMRC 0016)
includes an excerpt of the Aaron Copland interview

 

 

 

 

 


See the two books about the song
written by Shaker scholar, Roger Lee Hall,
and a biography of the Shaker leader
who wrote the song at this link:

Joseph Brackett's "Simple Gifts"

 

 

 

 

 

 

Giving credit where it is due!

In the book, Chosen Faith, Chosen Land by Jeannine Lauber (DownEast Books, 2009),
there are numerous errors in the description of Aaron Copland meeting Sister Mildred Barker as shown here:

 

© Photograph by Gail M. Hall, 1974

This is the caption underneath the picture:

Sister Mildred with Composer Aaron Copeland in Shaker Heights, Ohio in 1974. Sr. Mildred, Sr. Frances, and Br. Ted were in Ohio to conduct seminars during the Shaker bicentennial. They were invited to attend a birthday party for Mr. Copeland. He gave Sr. Mildred an autographed copy of his arrangement of "Simple Gifts."


Among the erros in this caption are Copland's name being misspelled twice.

No credit was given to who arranged this one time meeting meeting -- Roger Lee Hall, who also donated his personal copy of the sheet music for Copland to autograph.
Hall give the autographed copy to the Shakers for their library in Maine.

This picture also is not credited to the photographer. In addition, this meeting was not "a birthday party" for Copland. Instead, it was at a music librarian's home in Shaker Heights, Ohio where Copland had been invited to speak to graduate music students from Case Western Reserve University.

These are the facts not the fiction published in that book.

 

 

 

 


Extensxive research article about the Shaker song
and including highlights from the interview with Aaron Copland

"Simple Gifts: The Discovery and Popularity of a Shaker Dance Song"
by Roger Lee Hall in Communal Societies (Vol 36, No 2, 2016)

 

See this article from The Bulletin of The Society for American Music:

Aaron Copland’s “Simple Gifts” in Appalachian Spring

 

 

 

 

Recommended Recordings
of Copland's "Simple Gifts" Arrangements

 

There are many worthwhile versions of Copland's Appalachian Spring.

It still remains his most popular concert work in whatever version may be heard.

Copland also arranged the Shaker song for voice and piano (later orchestrated) in his set of Old American Songs.

Here are some recommended recordings:

 

The Music of America: Aaron Copland
a recommended 3 CD set with the variations
on"Simple Gifts"
from Appalachian Spring (Michael Tilson Thomas and
San Francisco Symphony), also the

arrangement of "Simple Gifts" sung by William Warfield
in Old American Songs

 

 

 

These recommended CDs are with Copland conducting:

A Copland Celebration Vol. 1 - Appalachian Spring (chamber version)
and other works including the "Simple Gifts" Variations

 

A Copland Celebration Vol. 2 - Old American Songs & other works
includes an arrangement of "Simple Gifts" for voice and piano
in
Old American Songs with
William Warfield, baritone and Aaron Copland, piano

A Copland Celebration Vol. 3 - Old American Songs & other works
orchestral arrangement of "Simple Gifts"
sung by William Warfield
(the distinguished baritone known for his role in Gershwin's Porgy & Bess)

 

For questions or comments

click here



Please help support the preservation mission of this website

See the Center for American Music Preservation

click here

 

 


Return to top of this page

 

   

 

     
   
   
   
 

© 2014 (Updated: 2024) PineTree Productions. All Rights Reserved.
No written material to be reproduced in a publication without prior permission.
For permission, contact: pinetreepro@aol.com