Film Music Review
The Sammy awards
Links
 
 

 

 
   

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Feature Presentations

 

Main Titles

Film Music Review Issues

100 Essential Film Scores

Film Focus Series

Best Film Music CDs of the Year and Decade

The Sammy Film Music Awards

Film Composer Tributes

Film Actor Music Tributes

Book and DVD Reviews

End Credits and Links

 


 

FILM MUSIC REVIEW

 

 

Editor-in-Chief:

Roger Hall



Contributing Writers:

Jeffrey Dane

Steven A. Kennedy

Steve Vertlieb

 

 

Member

IFMCA: the International Film Music Critics Association

See the nominations for 2009 awards at this link:

International Film Music Critics Association

 


 

Main Titles

 

Film Music Review Contents

Film Music Century

The Role of the Reviewer

Anniversary Specials

Film Music Guide


Please help suport

Film Music Review

Use this Search Box to order your merchandise from Amazon.com

  Enter keywords...

 


 


Film Music Review
Contents

 

For over a decade, Film Music Review (FMR) has provided reviews of CDs, DVDs, and Books.

It is now one of the longest-running online magazines devoted exclusively to film music.

This online magaizne was founded by Roger Hall, a film historian, writer and member of the International Film Music Critics Association. He has been the FMR editor since the beginning. Other writers who have assisted as Contributing Writers are:
Steven A. Kennedy, and Steve Vertlieb.

FMR began in 1998 on another website which lasted until 2005 and is no longer available online. All the reviews from those years have been archived and most are available as document files in the new eBook titled,

A GUIDE TO FILM MUSIC - Songs and Scores (PineTree Press, 4th edition)

FMR has been online here since 2006 and all the reviews are still available
(see the FMR Issues links below).

Over the years, FMR has been a respected resource for film music reviews and other news.

The focus of FMR now is on the preservation of film scores from the past,
devoted mainly to older soundtrack reisuues, re-recordings and other preservation efforts. Some new film scores are also occasionally reviewed.

Each year, FMR Editor Roger Hall lists his annual Sammy Awards for best film soundtracks, songs and other categories. These awards (also called the "Sammys") are named after the late great movie lyricist Sammy Cahn.

The Sammys are now the longest-running awards chosen exclusively for film music recordings.

 


Film Music Century

 

Music for the cinema was one of the most significant achievements
in popular entertainment during the 20th century.


It remains important in the 21st century as well, though many of the newer soundtracks lack the depth and quality of the older film scores and songs.

There are still film fans and critics who don't understand the importance of music in a film.

Music can be a major factor in the success of a film.

Just think of Max Steiner's monumental score for GONE WITH THE WIND,
Miklos Rozsa's haunting score in SPELLBOUND, Dimitri Tiomkin's memorable song and score in HIGH NOON, Bernard Herrmann's frightening music in PSYCHO,
the John Barry music in the James Bond films, or the thrilling scores of John Williams for the STAR WARS series. All of these scores contributed greatly to the success of those films. Many more could be listed.

Excluding the silent era when little original soundtrack music was recorded,
the music in sound films can be divided into these overlapping themes
during the 20th century
:

I. Hollywood Studio System
(Musicals and Scores):



1929 (BROADWAY MELODY)
to
1959 (BEN
HUR)



II. Theme Songs:


1952 (HIGH NOON)
to
1976 (THE OMEN)

III. Big Blockbusters:


1977 (STAR WARS)
to
1999 (TOY STORY 2)

The Role of the Reviewer

Over the years, I've read many comments in various newsgroups and message boards about soundtracks and movie musicals -- some have been fair and reasonable assessments, others are just personal ranting and raving.  On these message boards, soundtrack reviewers or critics are often criticized and attacked for their opinions.

This has been a trend that bothers me as a film music critic, since reviewers are often dismissed as morons, especially if someone disagrees with them.  The fact is that most reviewers offer their personal opinions of a CD soundtrack or compilation. You can agree or disagree with them, but it's not fair to dismiss them all as no-nothings.    

What then is the role of the reviewer?  I'll give my opinion for what it's worth...

As I see it, a reviewer is supposed to write a critical evaluation of a CD after carefully listening to it and relating it (if possible) to the film itself.  

Oftentimes the CD soundtrack is released before the film itself opens in movie theaters.  That makes assessment with how the music is used in a film very difficult.     

Here are three questions I consider when reviewing a CD soundtrack or compilation:

(1)   How does the music sound without from the film?

(2)   What is the film composer's score intended to accomplish?

(3)   Where are the strengths and weaknesses on the soundtrack CD album (the music, sound quality, notes, album design)?

It's not possible to consider each of these questions all the time.  For example, years ago I reviewed Christopher Gordon's superb score without having seen the television film, ON THE BEACH. It was unavailable at that time.  But I still evaluated the soundtrack based on what I heard.  I think that's okay because often the soundtrack is meant to stand on its own anyway.  That is why the track ordering is often different from the film, which drives some soundtrack collectors mad.  Who made the rule that soundtracks have to follow the same sequence as the film?  Collectors seem to think they are the only ones who matter when they demand that every second of the music be made available and in the same order as in the film. That is nonsense! I believe that most soundtrtack or compilation albums are meant to be enjoyable listening experiences, not rote reproductions of the original film soundtrack.    

Is it better to go along with the crowd or have your own opinion?

A good reviewer or critic MUST express his or her own opinion based on what they hear on the soundtrack, even if it offends the collectors or the film composer.  It seems to be a general rule that if you praise a soundtrack you're great, if you don't like one that's very popular  then you're an idiot.  So praise is good, criticism is not? I strongly disagree with that view.

If you just want to collect everything by such fan favorites as Jerry Goldsmith, John Williams, Hans Zimmer or (name your composer) then reviews may be of little interest for you.  Rabid soundtrack collectors are often very close-minded to other viewpoints.

On the other hand, if you'd like to read different opinions of a soundtrack before you decide to buy it, then reviews can be very helpful. That's why Film Music Review has been online for 11 years now. The objective of all reviewers on FMR have been to be as fair as possible when reviewing a soundtrack.  We don't praise something just because of the fame of the composer or the publicity hype for the film. 

Hopefully, after reading this essay, you'll have a better appreciation of what a reviewer does and if you like what they do, why not send them a message and let them know?

I believe that most reviewers work long and hard without ever getting much credit.

Naturally film composers and CD producers deserve credit for their outstanding work, but so do reviewers and critics.

So to all web site and print soundtrack reviewers, I salute you for your dedication to the film music cause!

To all soundtrack collectors, I wish you continued happy listening!


Roger  Hall, FMR Editor
July 2009  

 

Anniversary Specials

 

50th Anniversity Tribute

THE TWILIGHT ZONE Revisited

Bernard Herrmann's "Walking Distance"

 

KEN DARBY (1909 - 1992)

"RIVER OF NO RETURN"
A Centennial Tribute to Ken Darby

 

JOHNNY MERCER (1909-1976)

"Acent-tchu-ate The Positive"
Johnny Mercer in Hollywood

 

 

Film Music Review...

celebrated its 11th anniversary online in 2009.

To celebrate this occasion, see the lists of favorite film scores at

11th Anniversary Special

Read the picks from previous years at these links:

10th Anniversary Special

9th Anniversary Special

8th Anniversary Special

 

 

 

 

CD Review for

Hollywood's Greatest Hits (2 CDs)

 

 

 

 

 

Film Music Book

 

Now available!

The updated 4th edition with 50 audio files and
FMR CD reviews and news from 1998 to 2005,
all contained in the eBook titled:


A GUIDE TO FILM MUSIC: Songs and Scores

To read about this handy and useful reference guide
click on this link to

Film Composers and Soundtracks

 


 

Ratings for CDs and DVDs:

**** = Superlative (Highest Recommendation)

***1/2 = Very Good

*** = Good

**1/2 = Okay

** = Barely Passable

* = Poor

The Special Merit CDs are chosen for outstanding overall production of a soundtrack or compilation.

The Editor's Choice -- Best of the Month designation is for those CDs that are singled out for their excellence. They are chosen anytime within a given month and may not be chosen every month.

 

 

Film Music Review Issues

Volume 12, 2010

Number 1 (Winter)

Volume 11, 2009

Index to All Reviews (January - December)

Number 1 (Winter)

Number 2 (Spring)

Number 3 (Summer)

Number 4 (Fall)

Volume 10, 2008

Index to All Reviews (January - December)

Number 1 (Winter)

Number 2 (Spring)

Number 3 (Summer)

Number 4 (Fall)

 

Volume 9, 2007

Index to All Reviews (January - December)

Number 1 (January - February)

Number 2 (March - April)

Number 3 (May - June)

Number 4 (July - August)

Number 5 (September - October)

Number 6 (November - December)

 

Volume 8, 2006

Index to All Reviews (January - December)

Number 1 (January - February)

Number 2 (March - April

Number 3 (May - June)

Number 4 (July - August)

Number 5 (September - October)

Number 6 (November - December)


Index to CD, DVD and Book Reviews
(2006 - 2008)

 

Volumes 1 - 7 (1998-2005)

These reviews are no longer online.
For a complete list of soundtracks and compilations,
go to:

FMR Index


100 Essential Film Scores

 

 

For a survey from the 1930s to 1990s, see

100 Essential Film Scores of the 20th Century

 

 


Film Focus Series

 

Among the most appreciated film scores from the 1940s...

 

 

No. 1: Hugo Friedhofer and THE BEST YEARS OF OUR LIVES

by Steve Vertlieb and Roger Hall

 

 

A monumental historical score from the 1950s...

 

No. 2: Miklos Rozsa and PLYMOUTH ADVENTURE

by Roger Hall

 

 

The first major film score of the 1930s...

 

 

No. 3: Max Steiner and 75th anniversary of KING KONG

by Steve Vertlieb and Roger Hall

 

 

One of the great religious epic scores of the 1950s...

 

No. 4: Elmer Bernstein and THE TEN COMMANDMENTS

by Jeffrey Dane

 

 

Probably the greatest film score for a Hitchcock film...

 

No. 5: Bernard Herrmann and VERTIGO

by Roger Hall

 

 

 

An underrated score by the composer best known for his Western scores...

 

No. 6: Dimitri Tiomkin and IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE

by Roger Hall

 

 

 

 


The Best Film Music CDs

 

Best Film Music CDs of the Decade
(2000-2009)

 

Best Film Music CDs of 2009

 

Best Film Music CDs of 2008

 

 

 

Best Film Music CDs of 2007

 

 

Best Film Music CDs of 2006

 

 

Best Film Music CDs of 2005

 

 


The Sammy Awards

The Sammy Awards (or Sammys) are named after
the late movie lyricist, Sammy Cahn



The 22nd Annual Sammy Film Music Awards

will be announced on February 21, 2010.

Watch for the announcement!

Click on these links for the

21st Annual Sammy Awards

20th Annual Sammy Awards

19th Annual Sammy Award

18th Annual Sammy Awards

The Sammy Awards (Complete List)

 

 


Film Composer Tributes

 

Elmer Bernstein

"It's a junk culture, and people buy junk...generally speaking, film has not advanced in terms of taste and intelligence, and that makes it tough for music."
-- Elmer Bernstein

Read the Lifetime Achievement Award for Elmer Bernstein at

The Sammy Awards - 2005

A special remembrance by FMR Editor Roger Hall at:

80th Birthday Tribute to Elmer Bernstein

 

Aaron Copland on Film Music

 

"It’s quite expensive to add music to a film. It would be a shame if nobody paid attention to it (laughter). The producers would have thrown their money out the window." -- Aaron Copland

Read the interview by FMR Editor Roger Hall
with the distinguished composer Aaron Copland (1900-1990)
at this excellent site:

Runmovies/ Soundtrack

 

Something Wild

Read the review of Copland's last film score from 1961

SOMETHING WILD

 

Also available is "A Conversation with Aaron Copland" (AMRC No. 7)
available from the

American Music Recordings Collection

 

 

George Duning Centennial

 

George Duning 100th Anniversary

 

 

Jerry Goldsmith

 

 

 

"Each assignment becomes an agonizing experience. Where shall I begin? What notes shall I play? What combinations of sounds will be at once melodic and original and attention-grabbing that the audience will be hooked?"
-- Jerry Goldsmith

Read the Lifetime Achievement Award for Jerry Goldsmith at

The Sammy Awards - 2008

 

 

Bernard Herrmann: The Early Years

 

"Film music must apply what an actor cannot say. The music must really convey what the word cannot do. If you're dealing with an emotional subject
this is the complete purpose of a film score."
-- Bernard Herrmann (1911-1975)

 

He is one of the most admired film composers from the past.

Read the article by Roger Hall
about Bernard Herrmann and his early film scores,
with a new addendum of CDs
at this excellent site:

Runmovies/ Soundtrack

 

 

Hear excerpts of Herrmann's film music available on the CD
included with this reference book:

A GUIDE TO FILM MUSIC: Songs and Scores

 

 

Ennio Morricone

Honorary Oscar For Ennio Morricone

 

 

Miklos Rozsa Centennial

 


100th Birthday Tribute to Miklos Rozsa and Web Poll

 

Dimitri Tiomkin's "Golden Decade"

"In Hollywood vernacular, I could write commercial."
-- Dimitri Tiomkin (1894-1979)

Read Roger Hall's tribute to Hollywood's highest paid film composer of the 1950s, reprinted with a new addendum of recordings at

Runmovies/ Soundtrack

See "Dimitri Tiomkin's HIGH NOON" at

Film Composers and Soundtracks

 

Also read the DVD review of Dimitri Tionkin's monumental score for

THE FALL OF THE ROMAN EMPIRE

 

 

Franz Waxman

A Centenary Celebration

A Centennial Tribute To Franz Waxman

 

 

John Williams

John Williams
75th Birthday Tribute
and a Listener's Poll

 

 

 


Film Actor Music Tributes

 

""I have been uncompromising, peppery, intractable, monomaniacal, tactless, volatile, and oftentimes disagreeable...I suppose I'm larger than life." -- Bette Davis

She is one of the most admired Hollywood actresses from the past,
known for her distinctive acting, her demanding work ethic,
and those beautiful Bette Davis Eyes.

She was also fortunate to have some of the
best composers working in Hollywood for her films.

Read her biography and reviews of recommended soundtracks
from her classic films at

"They're Either Too Young or Too Old"

A Centennial Birthday Tribute to Bette Davis

 

“Well, I think one of the main things that you have to think about when acting in the movies is to try not to make the acting show.”
-- James Stewart

As with Bette Davis, James "Jimmy" Stewart was fortunate to have some of the best composers working in Hollywood for his films.
And like Ms. Davis, he also sang occasionally in his films.

Read all about it at this link:

"Easy to Love"

A Centennial Birthday Tribute to James Stewart

 

 


Book and DVD Reviews

 

Book Reviews

 

 

 

 

 

 

The Soundtracks of Woody Allen:
A Complete Guide to the Songs and Music in Every Film, 1969-2005
by Adam Harvey

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Hitchcock's Music by Jack Sullivan

 

 

 

 

Recommended Film Music Books

 

 

Here are several recommended books on film music for teaching purposes
or reading enjoyment...

 

 

 

 

The Art of Film Music(Paperback)
by George Burt

Comments: A very good textbook for aspiring film composers yet also worthwhile reading for any film music lover. Special emphasis on four film composers: Friedhofer, North, Raksin, Rosenman.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Film Music: A Neglected Art -- A Critical Study of Music in Films (Paperback -- by Roy M. Prendergast

Comment: A more technical study but worth reading.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The Invisible Art of Film Music (Paperback)
by Laurence E. MacDonald

Comments: An excellent non-technical survey from the 1920s to 1990s. Many illustrations and easy to read format.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Knowing The Score: Film Composers Talk About the Art, Craft, Blood, Sweat, and Tears of Writing for Cinema (Paperback)
by David Morgan

Comment: Fascinating interviews with film composers who offer insights into film scoring and collaborating with film directors.

 

 

 

 

Reel Music: Exploring 100 Years of Film Music

 

 

 

 

Reel Music: Exploring 100 Years of Film Music Paperback) -- by Roger Hickman

Comments: A comprehensive study with some analysis and an excellent survey overall.

 

 

 


Recommended DVDs
with film composer interviews

 

 

 

 

 

THE JOHNNY CARSON SHOW (Guest: composer Dimitri Tiomkin)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

THE PLOW THAT BROKE THE PLAINS & THE RIVER
-- music by Virgil Thomson (includes an audio interview)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


End Credits and Links

 

Film Music Review

is

owned and operated

by

PineTree Productions

 

For additional information, see these recommended

Film Music Links

 

Read the names of film composers who have been named to

The Tunemaker Hall of Fame

 

Click on this link for

Five Famous Films from 1956

 

There have been many film scores and songs chosen for this annual event:

Ninth National Carry A Tune Week (2009)

Eighth National Carry A Tune Week (2008)

Seventh National Carry A Tune Week (2007)

Sixth National Carry A Tune Week (2006)

Fifth National Carry A Tune Week (2005)


Send your comments
about this online magazine to:

Film Music Review

 

 

 


 

Search here for...

Film music


Please help support

Film Music Review

Use this Search Box for your purchases...

  Enter keywords...


Return to top of page

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
 
   
Contact  

© 1998-2010 PineTree Productions. All Rights Reserved. GMH Web Design.